Updated Program
as of November 21, 2003
IPPSO 2003 Conference
Completing the Power Equation:
What’s missing from the electricity market in Ontario?
November 25 & 26, 2003
Metro Toronto Convention Centre, South Building, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Featuring the Green Power Conference
(See below for program details)
Ontario’s power market has had its share of setbacks and challenges in the first year and a half, yet participants widely believe that the fundamentals are sound and the outstanding issues are amenable to a rational problem-solving process. Identifying the deficiencies that are most critical and the options for addressing them will be the chief focus of this landmark event. To achieve workable solutions, co-ordinated attention will have to be paid to the reliability requirements of the system, the commercial needs of participants, and the performance expectations of society at large. The central question which speakers will be asked to address: How to instill confidence that the Ontario market is an attractive place for long-term business investment.
All sessions will take place in the Metro Toronto Convention Centre, South Building, Room 801 A&B, unless otherwise specified.
Day 1 - Tuesday, November 25, 2003
7:30 am Daybreak coffee
Hosted by Access Capital and Northland Power
8:00 am Introductions by Conference Chairman, Safouh Soufi, SMS Energy-Engineering
The State of the Market
In speaking to “What’s missing from the electricity market in Ontario” panelists will address both whether it’s providing short term signals for efficient behaviour (through the hourly market, MIO, DAM, etc.) while also working to support the long-term stability and liquidity of the forward market (through LTRA, dependable demand response, bilateral contracting LMP, transmission planning, etc.) Each speaker will offer suggestions on how to address perceived market weaknesses where they exist.
8:15 am Keynote Speaker: Dave Goulding, CEO, Ontario Independent Electricity Market Operator
Questions and discussion
Concluding remarks by Donald Gibson, McCarthy Tetrault
9:00 am Sectoral Leaders Panel: What concerns are uppermost for the coming year?
Moderator: George Vegh, Macleod Dixon LLP
Charlie Macaluso, CEO, Electricity Distributors Association
Mary Ellen Richardson, President, Association of Major Power Consumers in Ontario
Judith Andrew, Canadian Federation of Independent Business
David McFadden, Chair, Stakeholders Alliance for Competition
John Brace, President, IPPSO
Julie Girvan, Consumers Association of Canada
Questions and discussion
10:15 am Coffee Break
Hosted by AMEC
Market Regulation
11:00 am How the Energy Board’s mandate impacts the achievement of the market’s objectives
Major change has been introduced in the mandate and legislation governing the Ontario Energy Board. How will this affect the market and how should participants expect to adjust their plans and practices to adapt to the new arrangements? If the objectives of the market are efficiency, reliability and competitive pricing, is the regulatory system taking us in the right direction?
Introduction: Phil Symmonds, Torys
Keynote: Howard Wetston, Chair, Ontario Energy Board
How the mandate of the Energy Board is being translated into actions to address the central objectives in the electricity market.
How Regulatory Reform will affect the energy market
Legal experts will present a quick-take version of their views on the following topical regulatory fronts: Transmission planning, consumer protection, obligation to supply, obligation to build, market power mitigation, upholding of rules designed for facilitation of competition, and who “owns” what responsibilities?
Moderator: David Lever, McCarthy Tetrault
David Brown, Stikeman Elliott LLP
Mark Rodger, Borden Ladner Gervais LLP
Tom Brett, Gowlings LLP
Peter Budd, Power Budd LLP
12 noon Lunch in the Trade Show
Hosted by Stikeman Elliott
Market Development / Investment Prospects
1:30 pm New Investment in the Ontario Electricity Sector
What signals do investors think they need to send capital here? What instruments are used elsewhere? Where are the strategic opportunities?
Moderator: Rod Macgillivray, CIBC World Markets
Part 1: What’s required to attract investment in generation?
John Young, Senior Vice President, Infrastructure and Legal Services, Borealis Capital Corporation
Michael Hogan, Senior Vice President, Upstream Gas and Power Generation, Direct Energy
Part 2: What’s required to attract longer-term investment in clean technologies?
Dr. Vicky J. Sharpe, CEO and President, Sustainable Development Technology Canada
2:30 pm Coffee Break
Hosted by Miller Thomson and Navigant
Market Operation
3:00 pm The practical options for redressing weaknesses in the system
How can the actual system be made more reflective of the principles it was intended to enact?
Moderator: Safouh Soufi, SMS Energy-Engineering
Kim Warren, IMO: Reliability in the context of NERC’s findings on the blackout
- Review of the events leading up to the blackout from the NERC report
- Ontario specific issues
- Direction of blackout investigation efforts - IMO, NPCC, NERC
Bob Gibbons, IMO: Generation planning and the capacity picture for Ontario over the next 5 - 10 years - what do the forecasts mean and how do they help participants?
- Methodology used and industry standards
- Review of 18 month and 10 year outlooks
- Impact of reserve shortfalls on the market
Don Tench, IMO: Where is the congestion on the IMO-controlled grid, and why so many seem to experience a shortage of information about congestion.
- Summary of where congestion historically occurs, frequency and magnitude
- Effects of congestion on the market (constrained on/off)
- Lake Erie circulation and it's impact on TLR's
- Managing congestion in the control room - tools, dispatch etc.
4:30 pm Annual General Meeting of IPPSO
Location: Room 802A
5:00 pm Reception in the Trade Show
Hosted by Torys LLP
6:00 pm Banquet Dinner
Location: Room 701 A&B
Hosted by Borden Ladner Gervais LLP
Keynote: The Hon. Dwight Duncan, Minister of Energy
Hedley Palmer Award
Day 2 - Wednesday, November 26, 2003
8:00 am Daybreak Coffee
Hosted by Probyn and Company and Sun Life Financial
Market Development
Break into three simultaneous streams: Market Operation, Transmission and Green Power
Stream 1: Current Developments in Market Operation
9:00 am Ontario’s Long-Term Resource Adequacy mechanism and consumer protection
What will it take to ensure adequate supply and system reliability in Ontario along with moderate prices? How much reliability should be considered a public necessity and how much a private good? Do we need a NERC-style reliability standard? The assessment of a market’s dynamic efficiency in practice hinges on a clear understanding of how adequacy will be assured, but how can this be reasonably accomplished? How are LTRA mechanisms expected to interact with transmission system planning and other market features?
Moderator: David Brown, Stikeman Elliott LLP
Jason Chee-Aloy, IMO, Independent Market Operator
David Brown, Ontario Energy Board
Carmine DiRuscio, Enersource
Rob Cary, Robert Cary & Associates Inc
10:00 am Coffee Break
Hosted by Power Budd LLP
10:30 am Day Ahead Market and LMP: What are the implications for market participants?
Moderator: David Brown, Stikeman Elliott LLP
Len Kula, IMO Independent Electricity Market Operator
John Chandley, LECG
Richard Way, TransAlta Energy
11:15 am Evaluating the effectiveness of Stakeholder participation in the IMO
Has the IMO’s stakeholdering been successful in comparison to the stakeholdering in other jurisdictions? What are the measures of effective stakeholdering in the context of Ontario’s IMO? What is the best way to connect stakeholdering and decision-making? Other than the stakeholder Board, are the ties between stakeholders and the IMO structure adequate for responsive and efficient governance? Is the IMO stakeholdering model in need of review? How can participation be made more effective and decision-making more responsive? What could be improved, and is continuous improvement feasible?
Moderator: David Brown, Stikeman Elliott LLP
Derek Cowbourne, Vice President of Market Services, IMO
David Goldsmith, Vice Chair, IMO Market Advisory Council
David Applebaum, Sithe Energies
Questions and discussion
Stream Two: Transmission
Location: Room 802B
10:30 am Transmission System Development - How is it working now?
These two panels are intended to uncover what a variety of independent analysts believe will be necessary to attract investment in transmission. The first panel will explore the present circumstances, their strengths and deficiencies, including:
- Who is responsible for what?
- Is the present structure of Hydro One appropriate for attracting new investment in Ontario?
- Who is willing to pay for new transmission under current conditions?
- What are the incentives to make investment and will it take place?
- What are the criteria for investment and what happens with a frozen tariff?
- The OEB’s view of the Transmission System Code
Moderator: Nazli Zeynep Uludere, London Economics
Gordon Ryckman, Ontario Energy Board
Carmine Marcello, Hydro One Networks
11:00 am Transmission System Development - How should it work in the future?
With the nature of the need established, the discussion will move on to identifying the preferred process for investment and what the resulting structure should be. Speakers will examine:
- What are the structural options for encouraging the building of new transmission?
- What’s it going to take to get investment in cross border transmission and how that would impact the internal Ontario system
- Who should be responsible for what?
Moderator: Nazli Zeynep Uludere, London Economics
Mark Graham, Director, Transmission Business Development, Hydro One Networks
Andrew Barrett, Vice President, Regulatory Affairs, OPG
12 noon Lunch in the Trade Show
Hosted by OPG - Ontario Power Generation Inc.
Market Development
1:15 pm Enhancing market liquidity - What can the LDCs do?
Can these market enhancements be successful unless the LDCs are engaged
in the implementation? Many proposals are afoot to enlarge the functions
of Ontario’s electricity distributors, from procurement under new models
for default supply, to accommodating distributed generation, to delivering
energy efficiency programs. Most of these reforms would involve rule changes,
regulatory changes and re-establishing the credit positions of many LDCs.
Which changes are most likely to occur, and which directions should the industry
be pushing?
Don Lechnar, OPG
Bill Hawkins, EDA - the Electricity Distributors Association
Jan Carr, Barker, Dunn & Rossi
Ron Clark, Power Budd
2:30 pm Coffee Break
Hosted by Vestas Canadian Windpower
Should Ontario forge ahead or change direction?
Introductory remarks: Dr. Allan Kupcis, Chair, Canadian Nuclear Association
3:00 pm Keynote: Duncan Hawthorne, CEO, Bruce Power
3:15 pm The Facts and the foreseeable surprises: Will we have enough properly-priced supply in Ontario?
Can the present market system be trusted to bring more supply to consumers efficiently and effectively? Are we on track to meet the key objectives of restructuring in terms of supply and price? Disruptions and dislocations can’t be predicted precisely, but they can be provided for. More difficult is providing for the possibility for regulatory change or political intervention. Each of these factors has its impact on planning and in order to facilitate investment, must be worked into planning projections. As participants compare views on where the greatest sensitivities lie, they will also be shedding light on the over-riding question for governments concerned with restructuring of the energy sector - Should we forge ahead or change direction?
Panelists are invited to speak to the following sets of concerns:
- The facts about Ontario supply in the coming years - will we have enough supply?
- What’s most likely to upset the forecast?
- What does it look like in the context of the risk of political intervention?
- How to ensure that accurate prices are combined with consumer protection
- How can the electricity sector be effectively de-politicized over time?
- How to achieve a reduced frequency of intervention
- Alternative ways of achieving regulatory independence
- Selling any new deal to the public
Moderator: Safouh Soufi, SMS Energy-Engineering
Nazli Zeynep Uludere, London Economics International
Marie Rounding, Elenchus Research Associates, former chair of the OEB
(Other speakers to be announced.)
4:00 pm Conclusion
With special thanks to our major sponsors:
Banquet: Borden Ladner Gervais LLP
Gold: London Economics International
and Enbridge Gas Distribution
Silver: Gowlings
Bronze: Macleod Dixon LLP
Reception: Torys LLP
Associate: McCarthy Tetrault LLP
Environment Canada
Lunch 1: Stikeman Elliott LLP
Lunch 2: Ontario Power Generation
Program details subject to change without notice.
For the latest information, contact IPPSO at 416-322-6549 fax 416-481-5785
sorayar@ippso.org www.newenergy.org/conf.html
Outline of Green Power Conference Program
Today’s business opportunities in Green Power
November 25 & 26, 2003
In association with IPPSO’s Canadian Power Conference, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, South Building, Toronto, Ontario - Room 803A
This event will provide the latest information for entrepreneurs interested in pursuing business opportunities in the market for green power, including municipalities and the various strategic partners. It will focus on how to make use of the many newly-developed incentives, overcome the barriers, and learn from the experience of those who have built successful green power companies. Featuring the top authorities in the field, this event will prepare delegates for the challenges of making the energy sector a cleaner and better understood part of the economy.
Day 1 - Tuesday, November 25, 2003
1:30 pm Opening Remarks- the context for green power development in Canada
Moderator: Mitch Rothman, Navigant Consulting Inc.
Matthew Bramley, The Pembina Institute, Update on the effectiveness of green power programs across Canada.
Julia Ciccaglione, Pristine Power: The prospects for improved policies and programs at the national level and the need for inter-group advocacy collaboration.
Deb Doncaster, OSEA - Ontario Sustainable Energy Association
On the economic and environmental benefits of green power, particularly focussing on community power
Speakers will be asked to address what to expect in terms of growth in Ontario’s green power sector.
2:00 pm Value-adding options for green power in Ontario
Moderator: Lisa DeMarco, MacLeod Dixon
Ontario’s Renewable Portfolio Standard: David Boileau, Renewable Energy Task Team
Emission Reduction Credits for NOx: Mike Butters, MBC Consulting
Kyoto targeted measures: Glen Estill
Attribute tracking in Ontario: Bunli Yang
3:00 pm Coffee Break
3:30 pm Green Certification Issues
Moderator: Jill Pritchard Scott, Ontario Ministry of Energy
Les Welsh, Environment Canada: Update on the status of the Environment Canada Guideline on Renewable Low-Impact Electricity and NAAIB
John Polak, TerraChoice: How to present a seamless system to consumers when Ecologo, Green-E, attribute tracking and others are operating simultaneously
Joyce McLean, Toronto Hydro: What changes Toronto Hydro would like to see.
4:00 pm Addressing the need for change in existing mechanisms
Mike Crawley, AIM PowerGen Corporation, moderator
Changes specific to wind power: Glen Estill, CanWEA
Changes specific to waterpower: Paul Norris, OWA
Changes specific to biomass: Eric Rosen, KMW Energy
Open, facilitated discussion on issues raised in the previous sessions.
Simultaneous, free-of-charge introductory public workshop alongside the Trade Show:
1:30 pm - 4:00 pm "Cogeneration, CHP and District Energy in Canada"
Manfred Klein, Environment Canada
(Location: 803B)
- Review of the various types of CHP projects across Canada with a focus on Ontario
- Why is Combined Heat & Power important?
- How important is energy conservation, system efficiency?
- Is use of waste heat "green energy" ?
- What is Quality of Energy?
- What are the Benefits, and the Implementation Barriers?
- Review of installed infrastructure
- What is future potential?
- How can this be realized?
- Roles of Federal/provincial governments, industry associations
Day 2 - Wednesday, November 26, 2003
8:30 am Opening Keynote: Jos Beurskens, Netherlands Energy Research Foundation ECN, Wind Energy Manager
Factors affecting the prospects for growth of wind power internationally and in Canada
9:00 am Distributed Generation: Is a break-through imminent?
Moderator: Edith Chin, Enbridge Gas Distribution
Industry Task Force on Distributed Generation: George Vegh, Macleod Dixon
Electricity Distributors Association: Darius Vaicunias, COLLUS Power
Developers: Peter Ronson, Toromont Energy
Paul Liddy, Mariah Energy Corp.
Regulator: Kirsten Walli on the OEB connection directive
10:00 am Coffee Break
10:30 am How to build successful municipal partnerships
Moderator: Ken Ogilvie, Executive Director, Pollution Probe
- John Warren, Director of Environmental Services, City of Toronto, What Toronto is looking for in a public/private partnership
- Sam Sidawi, Director of Operational Support Services with the Region of Niagara, Niagara’s Green Power Initiatives
- René Venendaal, BTG Biomass Technology Group, Netherlands, What makes a successful partnership
- Alex Bystrin, President of Oakville Hydro, Utility experience with landfill gas project development
- Douglas Salloum, Federation of Canadian Municipalities
12 noon Lunch break in the Trade Show
1:30 pm How to succeed with green power in Canada
Moderator: Richard Legault, Helimax Energy
Keynote: Jason Edworthy, Vision Quest Windelectric, Canadian wind energy developer
Keynote: John Sawler, Manager of Green Power Marketing, OPG, Marketing advice for green power entrepreneurs
Keynote: Stephen Probyn, Probyn and Company, Financing advice for green power entrepreneurs
Open discussion with facilitator on how to overcome the barriers to entry in the electricity business.
2:30 pm Conclusion
Program details subject to change without notice.
With special thanks to our Green Power Conference Sponsor: Environment Canada
For the latest information, contact IPPSO at 416-322-6549 fax 416-481-5785
sorayar@ippso.org www.newenergy.org/conf.html